Choosing The Right Pet Insurance (What You Need To Know)

dog and cat lying on the floor together

Choosing the right pet insurance can be challenging but it’s crucial for the long-term health of your pet.

Pet insurance is an essential safety net for managing your pet’s healthcare costs. It typically covers treatments for injuries, illnesses, and even inherited conditions. However, be aware of policy limits and exclusions, especially for pre-existing conditions. Understanding these details is crucial for choosing the right insurance for your pet’s lifetime care.

This guide covers everything from what pet insurance typically includes to understanding the nuances of policy limits and exclusions.

You’ll be equipped with the knowledge to make proper decisions about pet insurance, ensuring your pet’s health is protected without straining your finances.

What Does Pet Insurance Cover?

Pet insurance primarily serves as a financial safety net.

Pet insurance is designed to help pet owners manage the healthcare cost of their pets over its lifetime.

Typical coverage includes medical treatments for injuries, like fractures and wounds. And as well as illnesses such as infections, diabetes and cancer.

Pet insurance primarily serves as a financial safety net.

Some insurance options also cover inherited and birth-related conditions, providing support for problems common in certain pedigree breeds.

Most insurance solutions will also cover diagnostic tests, surgeries, hospital stays and medications.

Due to a growing demand for holistic veterinary care, some insurers even offer pet insurance options for physical therapy, acupuncture, etc.

Exclusions And Pre-Existing Conditions

A very important aspect of pet insurance is understanding its limitations especially when it comes to pre-existing health conditions.

These are ailments or injuries that your furry friend has before the insurance policy takes effect.

Most pet insurance providers exclude pre-existing conditions from coverage.

Although some might agree to cover the pre-exisiting health issue with higher premiums.

Always read and understand the fine prints when it comes to exclusions to prevent any claim issues when the need arises.

Policy Limits

Pet insurance policies come with specified limits which dictate the extent of coverage and the out-of-pocket costs for the pet owner.

Policy limits can be:

  • Annual
  • Per claim
  • Lifetime.

An annual limit caps the amount the insurer will pay in a given year, while per-claim limits restrict the coverage for each time you submit a claim.

Lifetime limits define the maximum amount the insurer will pay out over the pet’s lifetime.

Deductibles And Co-Payments

A lower deductible or co-pay often results in a higher premium.

Many pet owners are confused when it comes to deductitles and co-payments.

This is something that you need to be clear about as it dictates how much you need to pay out of your one pockets.

The deductible is the amount you pay out-of-pocket before the insurance kicks in.

After the deductible is met, the co-pay is the percentage of the covered expenses that you’re responsible for.

A lower deductible or co-pay often results in a higher premium.

Here’s a simple example.

Imagine you have a pet insurance policy with a $200 annual deductible and a 20% co-payment.

Deductible: Your pet gets sick, and the vet bill is $500.

First, you pay the $200 deductible out of your pocket.

After Deductible: Now, the remaining bill is $300 ($500 – $200).

Co-Payment: You are responsible for 20% of this remaining $300, which amounts to $60.

Insurance Pays: The insurance company covers the rest, which is $240.

So, in total, for a $500 vet bill, you pay $260 ($200 deductible + $60 co-payment), and the insurance covers $240.

When Is The Best Time To Purchase Pet Insurance?

puppy playing with woman finger

The short answer is, as soon as possible once you have gotten your pet.

Understanding when you need pet insurance is crucial as timing can greatly impact the coverage and the premium that you pay.

A great time to start thinking about pet insurance is when you first adopt or purchase a pet.

This is when your pet is still young and healthy.

Insuring your pet at a young age ensures broader coverage since it less likely to have developed any health issues.

Insurance premiums are generally lower for younger pets.

As your pet ages, the risk of health issues increases, leading to higher insurance costs.

Pet Insurance For Older Pets

Not all pet owners have a young pet to insure.

Many of us prefer to get an older or senior pet for various reasons.

Insuring an older pet has its limitations as compared to a younger one.

Age Restrictions

Many pet insurers have a cut off age of 10 years old for new polices.

It’s important to check if there’s a maximum age for starting a policy if you have an older pet.


When you enroll an older pet, the insurer might require a thorough examination by a veterinarian.

This helps determine pre-existing conditions which the insurer will most likey exclude from its coverage.

Higher Premiums

Premiums for older pets are a lot higher. The difference between a 8 year old vs 10 year old can be more than a $100 each month.

Who Pays The Bill First?

The workings of who pays the vet bill first can have an impact on your choice of pet insurer.

There are some insurers that will require you to make the full payment of the bill first.

Once your make the claim with the required documents, the insurer will reimburse you back the amount after factoring the deductible and co-payment.

Other insurers have plans that pay the vet directly when its time to settle the bill.

You only have to take care of your share of co-payment.

Advantages Of Direct Payment

Opting for pet insurance plans that pays the vet clinic directly offers several key advantages.

Reduced Upfront Costs

With direct vet payment, you’re not required to pay the full cost of veterinary services.

Pet hospitalization and surgeries can run into the tens of thousands.

This can be an issue if you do not have the finances to pay upfront first.

You have peace of mind knowing that the insurer will handle the bulk of the bill.

Eliminating Reimbursement Wait Times

If you have ever done an insurance claim before, it can take weeks or even months for it to be approved.

You won’t have to wonder when you will get your money back.

This can be frustrating if you have to keep chasing the insurer for updates.

Immediate Claim Approval

Once the bill is settled by the insurer at the vet’s clinic, everything is done and dusted.

There’s no need for you to further submit a claim to approve the bill.

Everything is sent electronically to the insurer by the vet.

Is Pet Insurance Worth The Investment?

It reduces the immediate out-of-pocket expenses, making essential and sometimes life-saving treatments more accessible and affordable for pet owners.

There are always 2 sides of the coin when it comes to getting pet insurance.

Some pet owners swear by it while other strongly feel that it is a waste of money.

You should assess its value and benefits against the potential costs before making the decision.

Understanding The Cost-Benefit Ratio

Pet insurance provides financial protection against the often high vet bills.

It is common for emergency and specialized treatments to cost more than tens of thousands.

By covering a range of expenses, it can help you manage the financial burden of keeping your healthy.

It reduces the immediate out-of-pocket expenses, making essential and sometimes life-saving treatments more accessible and affordable for pet owners.

Savings Account Vs Pet Insurance

Some pet owners feel that it is better to deposit the monthly premium into a savings account instead of pet insurance.

The good thing about this method is that if your pet doesn’t incur any hefty medical bills in its lifetime, you get to keep the remainder of the savings.

The downside is that you might not have saved up enough funds to pay for a sudden expensive vet bill.

This can leave you financially exposed.

In contrast, pet insurance offers a more dependable safety net as it provides timely coverage for any major veterinary treatment.

Peace Of Mind

Pet insurance offers peace of mind to the pet owner.

Knowing that you’re prepared for unexpected pet health issues with reduces stress and allows you to focus on what’s most important, recovery.

This assurance enables you to make healthcare decisions for your pet based on medical necessity and not budget limitations.

It will be a very tough call to make when it coms to deciding between saving your pet or your last $5000 in your ban account.

It is a small price to say for peace of mind.

Should You Switch Pet Insurers?

While all pet insurance plans offer a safety net, coverage can vary significantly.

There might come a time when feel the need to switch pet insurers.

It is important to compare pet insurance if you have plan to switch insurers.

Here’s a guide on when it might be a good time to switch and what to look out for before making the change.

When To Consider Switching

Premium Increases

If your current insurer significantly raises premiums without improving coverage, it might be time to look for more cost-effective options.

Changes In Pet’s Health

As your pet gets older or has certain medical needs, it might call for different coverage requirements.

If your current policy no longer suits these needs, switching could be beneficial.

Better Deals

The global pet insurance market is expected to reach USD 11.25b by 2026.

As more pet owners see the need for pet insurance, pet insurers are always coming up with better deals to attract customers.

If you find another insurer offering better coverage, lower premiums or more tailored options, switching could be advantageous.

When Not To Consider Switching

Pre-Existing Conditions

Be cautious if your pet has any pre-existing health issues.

New insurers might not be willing to cover these as conditions when you make the switch.

Long Waiting Periods

It is important to note that many insurers impose a mandatory waiting period for new policies.

This is prevent any form of claim abuse by the customers.

The waiting period can range from a few months to even a year.

Switching insurers might mean new waiting periods before the policy becomes effective, leaving a gap in coverage.

Checklist When Buying Pet Insurance


It can be a herculean task when it comes to choosing the right insurance for your pet.

I have created a checklist which covers the most of the important aspects to look out for.

Personally, I don’t feel that there’s a particular pet insurer that rules the roost, so to speak.

But I prefer to stick to the more established ones such as Embrance, Trupanion, Pets Best, etc.

Here’s a checklist to help you confidently find pet insurance that ensures comprehensive care for your pet.

1. Assess Customer Service Quality

Some might beg to differ but I strongly feel that exceptional customer service is a big deciding factor for me.

When your pet is sick and you are feeling anxious, the last thing you want to be dealing with is rude or incompetent support stuff if there’s issues with your policy.

Contact the insurer’s customer service to gauge their responsiveness and helpfulness.

2. Get Quotes From Several Insurers

Don’t just sign up with the first pet insurer that you see.

Get a few quotes form different insurers to see what’s being offered in the market for a thorough comparison.

Ensure you’re comparing similar levels of coverage for a fair assessment.

3. Examine Sample Policies

Obtain and thoroughly read sample policies.

Pay special attention to the details, including waiting periods, to fully understand what is covered and what is not.

4. Clarify Deductible Terms

Determine whether the deductible is annual (based on the policy start date) or follows the calendar year.

This affects how often you’ll need to meet the deductible.

5. Understand Co-Payment Terms

Co-payment is the percentage of the vet bill you are responsible for paying after the deductible is met.

It’s important to know this rate as it affects your out-of-pocket expenses during a claim.

6. Check Coverage Maximums

Identify the payout limits on coverage, including per-incident, annual and lifetime maximums.

These caps can significantly impact the policy’s usefulness in case of major medical expenses.

7. Research Breed-Specific Conditions

If you know your pet’s breed, research common health problems and ensure the policy covers these conditions.

8. Understand Policy Exclusions

Different insurers will have different exclusions, depending on their risk appetite.

This is in top of the pre-exisiting health issues that your pet is excluded from for coverage.

9. Clarify Claims Process

Understand the steps involved, from how to submit a claim to the time frame for processing and reimbursement.

10. Read Customer Reviews

A great way to find out more about a pet insurer is to read online reviews and ask around in the forums.

11. Review Renewal Terms

Understand how the policy might change upon renewal, including potential increases in premiums or changes in coverage, especially as your pet gets older.

Leave a Comment